Home Resources Hit a Deer? Auto Guide
Auto Guide

Hit a Deer in Indiana? What Car Insurance Covers

Deer collisions spike every fall on Wabash Valley roads. Whether your claim is paid, and which deductible applies, depends on one detail most drivers never think about.

5 min readUpdated November 17, 2026
RW
Robert Wilson InsuranceLicensed Indiana agents · Terre Haute since 1975

Indiana drivers hit thousands of deer every year, and November is the worst month. If it happens to you, here is how the claim works and what to do in the first ten minutes.

Why November is the riskiest month

Fall is breeding season for white-tailed deer, and the Indiana Department of Natural Resources says activity peaks in the first half of November. Harvest is wrapping up at the same time, so deer have less cover in the fields, and the time change puts the evening commute right at dusk, when deer move most.

Indiana State Police recorded more than 16,000 crashes involving deer in 2023. On the rural stretches of US 41, US 40, and county roads around Terre Haute, Brazil, Sullivan, and Rockville, deer strikes are one of the most common auto claims we help with.

Comprehensive vs. collision: the detail that decides your claim

What happenedCoverage that usually appliesWhy it matters
You hit the deerComprehensiveTreated like hail or theft, not an at-fault accident
You swerved to miss the deer and hit a tree, guardrail, or ditchCollisionCan carry a higher deductible and may be rated as an at-fault crash
You only carry liabilityNothing for your own carLiability pays other people, never your vehicle

That is why safety experts and insurers give the same advice: do not swerve. Brake firmly, hold your lane, and let the vehicle stop. Swerving into oncoming traffic or off the road is far more dangerous than the deer, and it can also move your claim from comprehensive to collision.

Check your comprehensive deductible

Many drivers set a $1,000 comprehensive deductible to save a few dollars and forget about it. A deer strike often runs a few thousand dollars in repairs on a newer vehicle, with sensors, headlamps, and a radiator all in the crumple zone. If your deductible is high, it is worth pricing a lower one before winter.

What to do right after you hit a deer

  • Get off the road safely. Pull onto the shoulder if the car is drivable, turn on your hazard lights, and stay buckled while you collect yourself.
  • Stay away from the deer. An injured deer can kick hard. Do not try to move it or check on it.
  • Call the police when the law requires it. Indiana law requires you to notify law enforcement when a crash causes an injury, a death, or property damage above the state's $1,000 threshold, which a deer strike easily passes. A police report also makes the claim simpler.
  • Photograph everything. The damage, the road, the deer if it is safe to do so, and any hair or blood on the vehicle. Photos are the easiest proof the damage came from an animal.
  • Do not drive a damaged car at night. A broken headlight, leaking radiator, or loose bumper can turn one problem into two. If in doubt, tow it.
  • Call us before you call a body shop. We can open the claim with your carrier, tell you which coverage applies, and explain your deductible.

Can I keep the deer?

In Indiana, if a deer dies after a collision, a conservation officer, DNR property manager, or other law enforcement officer can issue a permit allowing a person to possess it. Do not take it without that permit.

Motorcycles and deer

A deer strike on a motorcycle is a far more serious event. Riders should carry comprehensive and collision on the bike, plus medical payments and uninsured motorist coverage. See our motorcycle insurance page.

Will a deer claim raise my rates?

A comprehensive claim for hitting an animal is generally not treated as an at-fault accident, so it usually has less effect on your premium than a collision claim. Every carrier rates claims history differently, though, and several claims in a short period can still matter. If you are unsure whether to file a small claim, call us and we will talk it through.

Review your auto policy before winter

If you are not sure whether you have comprehensive coverage, or what your deductible is, call (812) 234-0766. We will check your declarations page and compare carriers if a lower deductible makes sense. You can also read our auto insurance overview or what Indiana's 25/50/25 minimum covers.

This guide is general information, not a statement of coverage. Every policy's terms, limits, and exclusions differ by carrier and by state filing. Talk with a licensed agent about your specific situation before making coverage decisions.

Ready for a Free Quote?

Call us or send a message. No obligation, no pressure — just a licensed Indiana agent comparing your options across multiple carriers.